Introduction
The CIA Triad—Confidentiality, Integrity, and Availability—is an information security model that serves as the cornerstone for developing robust and resilient cybersecurity policies. While each component of the triad is critical, the terms “accessibility” and “availability,” which often fall under the ‘Availability’ part of the CIA Triad, are frequently used interchangeably. This creates a conceptual confusion that may result in the implementation of less-than-optimal security controls.
As a CISSP (Certified Information Systems Security Professional), I’d like to clarify the nuances between accessibility and availability within the realm of cybersecurity, specifically as they relate to the CIA Triad.
What is the CIA Triad?
Before diving into the nuances, it’s essential to have a foundational understanding of the CIA Triad.
- Confidentiality: Ensures that only authorized individuals can access specific data.
- The opposite of this is unauthorized disclosure.
- Integrity: Guarantees that the data remains unaltered and trustworthy during its lifecycle.
- The opposite of this principle is alterations that are not allowed.
- Availability: Makes sure that authorized users have consistent and timely access to resources.
- The opposite of this part of the triad is destruction – of the data, the systems, or the networks to the resources.
Accessibility
Definition
Accessibility generally refers to the design of systems that can be easily understood and operated by as many people as possible. This can include—but is not limited to—individuals with disabilities.
Security Implications
In cybersecurity, accessibility does play a role but typically isn’t a primary consideration in the CIA triad. Poor accessibility can affect availability in specific scenarios. For example, if a system is designed with poor user interfaces that don’t cater to people with disabilities, the ‘Availability’ of the system for that user group may be compromised. This is why availability is sometimes confused with accessibilty.
Accessibility Recommendations
- User Interface (UI) and User Experience (UX) design considerations
- Compliance with ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act) and Section 508
- Regular audits to ensure accessibility criteria are met
Availability
Definition
Availability, on the other hand, ensures that a system is operational and accessible to authorized users when they need it. This involves myriad aspects such as server uptime, data redundancy, and failover solutions, such as immutable backups.
Security Implications
Availability is a core aspect of the CIA Triad. An unavailable system can have critical repercussions, such as lost revenue and brand damage. Cybersecurity attacks, like Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) attacks, directly target the availability of services.
Availability Best Practices
- Redundancy and Failover systems
- DDoS protection mechanisms
- Backup and Disaster Recovery Plans
Key Differences
- Scope: Accessibility is often specific to user experience, while Availability has a broader scope involving infrastructure, network, and data.
- Legal Implications: Accessibility has more legal constraints (e.g., ADA compliance) as compared to availability.
- Primary Concern: Accessibility may be viewed as a subset or special case of availability, but it usually isn’t the primary concern in cybersecurity.
Conclusion
Both accessibility and availability are essential aspects of a well-rounded cybersecurity posture, but they serve different purposes and have different implications. While accessibility aims at ensuring that as many people as possible can easily use a system, availability focuses on making sure the system is up and running for authorized users when needed.
Understanding these nuances is critical for developing effective cybersecurity policies that adequately protect against a broad spectrum of risks. It ensures that your cybersecurity approach is not only robust but also inclusive, covering all aspects of the CIA Triad.
If you have further questions or need a deeper dive into any of the aspects discussed, feel free to reach out.
Don’t miss out on any new content – subscribe to our blog!
